From 6 April 2027, grief will come with a new piece of paperwork. If someone dies on or after that date with money left in their pension, that money will be counted as part of their estate for inheritance tax. The Finance Act 2026 made it law in March. The Government calls it closing a loophole. I call it one of the least thought through tax changes I have seen in my career.
I trained as a chartered accountant, so I say this with some care: the problem is not only what is being taxed. It is who has been handed the job of sorting it out.
The answer is the personal representative. In plain English, that is usually the widow, the son, the daughter or the old friend who agreed years ago to act as executor. Under the new rules they are responsible for finding every pension the person held, getting a value for each one, working out the tax, reporting it to HMRC and paying it.
They must do this for assets they do not control. A pension sits with a scheme or a provider, not in the estate. The executor cannot log in and may not even know the pot exists. Yet the responsibility for getting it right falls on them. Ministers point to new mechanisms: executors can ask a scheme to hold back up to half of the benefits for up to 15 months, or to pay the tax directly. But each of those is another form, another request, another scheme to chase. They manage the problem. They do not remove it.
Then there is the clock. Inheritance tax is due six months after the end of the month of death. After that, interest starts to run. Anyone who has tried to get a valuation out of a pension administrator, or chased an old workplace scheme from a job held thirty years ago, will know how fast six months disappears. People change jobs many times. Small pots get forgotten. The Government's own pensions dashboard, which is meant to help people find lost pensions, is not expected to open to the public until the 2027 to 2028 financial year. The tax arrives first. The tool to find the pensions arrives later.
Ministers say there will be help. HMRC promises interactive tools and guidance by April 2027. The rules on what schemes and executors must tell each other were only laid in July. Guidance for the industry is still in draft, further regulations are still to come, and the final guidance for families is not due until spring 2027. In other words, with months to go, the families, solicitors and pension schemes who must operate this system still do not have the full rulebook. That is not how you introduce a major tax change. That is how you create errors, delays and penalties.
Consider what delay means in practice. Probate can already take many months. Add a hunt for pension valuations and a tax calculation that depends on every one of them, and families will wait longer for the money they need. Funeral costs do not wait for HMRC.
There is a fairness point too, and it matters. Since the pension freedoms of 2015, savers have been told that pensions were a sensible place to keep long term savings, including savings they might one day pass on. They planned on that basis. Many deliberately spent other savings first and left the pension until last, because those were the rules and that was the advice. You cannot rerun your sixties. A person of 75 who followed the rules faithfully cannot now go back and arrange their affairs differently. Changing the terms after people have made irreversible decisions corrodes trust in saving itself.
For some families the bill will be severe. Pensions left to a husband, wife or civil partner remain exempt. But pensions left to children, or to a partner who never married, are exposed. Inheritance tax is charged at 40%. Where the saver died aged 75 or over, those who inherit what is left can then pay income tax when they draw it. Two taxes on the same pot, with an effective rate that can approach 67%. Ministers have not explained why they think that is a reasonable outcome.
The Government likes to suggest this is about the very wealthy. But the inheritance tax threshold remains frozen at £325,000. Yes, there is an extra allowance for passing on a home to children, but it tapers away for larger estates and does nothing for those without children or without a home to leave. The average house price is c.£270,000; add a modest pension pot built over forty years of work and a household that has never thought of itself "rich" can find itself over the line. This is a tax on people who did the right thing: worked, saved, bought a home and tried not to be a burden.
And for what? The measure is expected to raise around £1.46 billion a year by 2029 to 2030. That is real money, but it is small against the scale of public spending, and it comes at a heavy cost in complexity. Industry voices have already urged the new Chancellor to think again. AJ Bell has called this the worst way to tax pensions on death, and proposed simpler options, such as a flat charge on inherited pots or taxing beneficiaries through income tax. When those who run the schemes say the method is wrong, a wise minister would listen.
So I have some questions for the Treasury:
Will families see the final guidance in time to understand it?
What protection will an executor have if a pension turns up after the tax has been paid?
Has any assessment been made of how much longer probate will take?
Does the Government still stand by its estimate that around 8% of estates will be affected, and how many of those belong to people who would never describe themselves as wealthy?
And what is the plan if schemes simply cannot supply valuations inside the deadline?
These are not political questions. They are the practical questions any accountant would ask before signing off a new system. None has yet had a satisfactory answer.
A tax system should be certain, simple and fair. This change fails all three tests. It is uncertain, because the guidance is still being written. It is complicated, because it asks grieving relatives to do the work of a tax office. And it is unfair, because it punishes people for following the advice they were given.
The Chancellor has a Budget on 28 October. He inherited this policy. He does not have to own its failures. Will he tell bereaved families, before next April, exactly what he expects of them?